Comparison

Cold dark shell vs. warm vanilla shell vs. second-generation space

The delivery condition in the LOI moves a tenant’s build-out by $100–$300+ per square foot. A bigger allowance on a colder shell is often the more expensive deal.

Commercial interior under construction with bare walls, exposed conduit boxes and a ladder

Side-by-side matrix

 Cold dark shellWarm vanilla shellSecond-generation
Also calledGray shell, raw shellWhite box, vanilla boxPreviously built-out, “as-is”
Typically deliveredStructure, roof, slab, storefront or exterior wall, utility stubs to the suiteBase HVAC, ceiling grid and lighting, taped perimeter drywall, a base restroom, electrical panelThe prior tenant’s walls, ceilings, MEP and finishes
HVACNone inside the suite — distribution adds $15–$30/SFBase units and main ducts; zoning changes extraExisting; may not match the new layout or load
ElectricalNo distribution — adds $10–$20/SFPanel and lighting grid; branch circuits extraExisting; panel capacity to verify
Plumbing & restroomsStubs only; slab trenching for every fixtureOne base restroom; added fixtures trenchedExisting, often not ADA compliant
Tenant construction$60–$150+/SF standard · $200–$350+/SF medical / restaurant$35–$90/SF$5–$10/SF cosmetic · $25–$70/SF reconfiguration
Typical TI allowance$30–$60+/SF$10–$30/SF$10–$25/SF
Permit pathFull new-interior permit set with all MEP disciplinesStandard TI permitFastest if cosmetic; ADA and code audit if altered
Time to openLongestMediumShortest

Source: Meade Design 2025–2026 U.S. fit-out benchmarks. Construction-only ranges for light-to-standard finish programs.

Worked example

Why $50/SF on a cold shell can cost more than $15/SF on a second-gen suite

Two 3,000 USF office suites in the same submarket, both quoted on RSF with a 10% load factor (3,300 RSF), same tenant program.

 Cold dark shellSecond-gen reconfiguration
Tenant construction$120/SF × 3,000 = $360,000$45/SF × 3,000 = $135,000
Design & permit (≈ 14%)$50,400$18,900
Contingency (12%)$43,200$16,200
Project cost$453,600$170,100
TI allowance on 3,300 RSF$50/SF = $165,000$15/SF = $49,500
Tenant cash gap$288,600$120,600

Illustrative midpoints from Table 3 of the 2026 benchmarks; excludes furniture, technology and specialty MEP.

The extra $115,500 of allowance covers only about 40% of the extra $283,500 in project cost. The second-generation suite leaves the tenant $168,000 better off — if its layout really fits, which is what a test fit proves.

Run your own suites

How to choose

  • Choose second-generation when at least 70% of the existing walls, restrooms and MEP serve your program — the fastest opening and lowest capital.
  • Choose a warm vanilla shell when you need a custom layout but want base systems the landlord has already paid for.
  • Choose a cold dark shell when the location is decisive, the term is long, and the landlord’s allowance and free rent reflect the full build-out — common for restaurants and medical users with heavy plumbing.
  • In every case, write the delivery condition into the LOI as a specific list (HVAC tonnage, electrical amperage, restroom count, ADA entrance), not a label. “Vanilla shell” means different things to different landlords.

Have a suite under LOI?

Send the floor plan and the work letter. We will tell you what fits, what it costs and what the allowance leaves uncovered.

Request a Test Fit